March 14, 2019
Audrey Yates (Irias)
Learning when to use ser versus estar is always a challenge. I have to come back to it and review it every year. I remember back when I was in my Syntax class in college that we spent a whole month reviewing it! I would tell my students to take comfort in the fact that Spanish majors needed a whole month to review a concept in an in-depth grammar class that they learned back in Spanish 1. That did help them feel better. That, and reminding them that learning a language is a process and Rome wasn’t built in a day.
I have taught ser and estar the “old-fashioned” or “traditional” way, with conjugation grids and mnemonic devices. The students knew the conjugations and each mnemonic device inside and out. They could conjugate them and put them into sentences, but still, when it came down to it, would struggle if one sentence had an instance to use ser and the next sentence, estar.
I decided to shake things up and make learning more organic, rather than a prescriptive approach. I would find pop or reggaetón songs in Spanish, and have them read along with me three times, as they would fill in a cloze-activity exercise with aforementioned vocabulary. We would then have a recognition-based discussion, where they would partner up and guess what the various forms of ser and estar meant in that song, which would lead to them both meaning a form of “to be.”
Here are some samples of those songs:
I recommend adding “
Before going deep into the “when do I use which,” I would show students snippets from different types of media, based in Spanish-speaking countries. Again, I would ask them what they thought it meant, besides answering comprehension questions. The more they saw the verbs in different contexts, the more they were able to pick up when to appropriately use them.
Here is some poetry I could use:
https://www.poemas-del-alma.com/blog/mostrar-poema-398199 and https://www.poemas-del-alma.com/blog/mostrar-poema-228336. For other types of media, I can search for expressions used with conjugations of each verb at https://www.linguee.com/spanish-english/translation/ and check out those websites in the Spanish column. Be sure to find the website you want before class time, because while they may appear on Linguee, that doesn’t mean the website is still up and working.
It isn’t until after I spend two weeks going back and forth do I broach the conjugation or “when to use” discussion—less time for more advanced classes. I still review it, even for my advanced classes, in case there are any doubts or I clear up something they didn’t know they misunderstood. But, by this time, most students are able to use both verbs correctly in
Please note that the websites worked at the time of publishing this blog and as I am not their creator, I cannot promise that they will continue working. I hope, however, that this blog helps you when you teach ser versus estar.
Posted By Audrey Yates (Irias) | Teacher’s Discovery
Audrey Yates (Irias) started learning Spanish at age 10 in a FLEX program in her elementary
How useful was this post?
Click on a star to rate it!
No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.
We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!
Tell us how we can improve this post? If you would like a response, please include an email address.
Thanks for your feedback!