New York Moves to Ban Flavored E-Cigarettes by Emergency Order

The state would become the second in the nation, behind Michigan, to outlaw sale of the fruity flavors popular with children and teenagers.

September 16, 2019
Jesse McKinley and Christina Goldbaum
NY Times

Amid a surge of vaping-related illnesses and deaths, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo of New York announced on Sunday that he would pursue emergency regulations this week to quickly ban the sale of flavored e-cigarettes.

The governor’s action comes days after President Trump announced an effort to ban similar vaping products at the federal level. If New York does outlaw flavored e-cigarettes, it would become the second state to move toward such a ban, following Michigan, which announced earlier this month that it would prohibit such products.

Speaking from his office in Midtown Manhattan, Mr. Cuomo described a growing health crisis, likening it to illnesses related to traditional tobacco products.

“Vaping is dangerous. Period,” the governor, a third-term Democrat, said, outlining a variety of potential health concerns associated with the practice, including encouraging nicotine addiction. “No one can say long-term use of vaping—where you’re inhaling steam and chemicals deep into your lungs—is healthy.”

Under the plan outlined by Mr. Cuomo on Sunday, the state’s Public Health and Health Planning Council, a little-known regulatory body, would be convened by the health commissioner, Dr. Howard Zucker. The council would then issue an emergency regulation to ban the sale of flavored e-cigarettes, rules that would take effect immediately.

State and federal actions related to flavored e-cigarettes come as health officials around the country continue to grapple with an outbreak of a severe lung disease linked to vaping that causes severe shortness of breath and days of vomiting, fever and fatigue. At least six deaths and hundreds of hospitalizations have been reported.

New York State has had 64 cases of the lung disease linked to vaping, Dr. Zucker said. “We need to tackle this as fast as possible,” he said, adding, “We don’t need to repeat history.”

Tobacco and menthol-flavored products would not be covered by the ban, the governor said, saying some data suggests that those menthol products could assist in helping people to stop smoking traditional cigarettes. Mr. Cuomo’s office said that a menthol ban was possible in the future, depending on what health officials conclude.

Still, the decision not to immediately include menthol drew a sharp rebuke from the American Lung Association, which said Mr. Cuomo had missed “the opportunity to take decisive action.”

“While today’s announcement was well-intentioned, it will drive our youth to use menthol-flavored products in even greater numbers,” said Harold Wimmer, the association’s president. He called on the State Legislature to pursue a broader ban on all flavored tobacco products.

Austin Finan, a spokesman for Juul Labs, which dominates the e-cigarette market, said the company was reviewing the governor’s announcement but agreed with “the need for aggressive category-wide action on flavored products.” Juul Labs, he said, had already stopped selling flavored pods in “traditional retail stores.”

The company “will fully comply with local laws and the final F.D.A. policy when effective,” Mr. Finan added.

Mr. Cuomo’s action came less than a week after the state announced a series of other measures meant to address both the surge of vaping illnesses and the expanding use of e-cigarettes—sleek devices that often resemble gaming styluses or USB flash drives—by minors, including subpoenaing records from several companies that make vaping products.

Though the specific substance or product causing the vaping illnesses remains unclear, the New York State Department of Health has linked many cases of the illness to cannabis products that contain high levels of vitamin E acetate, a thickening agent for vaping liquid. Vitamin E acetate is now a key focus of the department’s inquiry.

In July, the governor signed a bill raising the age to 21 for anyone wishing to buy tobacco or electronic-cigarette products. That new age limit takes effect in November; on Sunday, Mr. Cuomo promised the State Police would conduct undercover investigations of retailers to ensure that all smoking-related laws are followed.

New York’s former mayor, Michael R. Bloomberg, a champion of anti-tobacco efforts, announced a $160 million push to ban flavored e-cigarettes in at least 20 cities and states.

As news of Mr. Cuomo’s announcement spread on Sunday, some e-cigarette vendors in the city said they were wary of the attempt to curb the little-regulated $2.6 billion industry and the roughly 20,000 vape shops nationwide.

If a ban were to go into effect, “my business is dead,” said Amit Patel, 38, an employee at E Smoke & Convenience in Manhattan. Mr. Patel estimated that 70 percent of business at the shop came from the dozens of flavors of e-cigarettes he sells, including Swedish Fish and Pink Lemonade.

Some e-cigarette users who turned to vaping products to quit traditional cigarettes said the ban could mean a return to old habits.

Douglas Horowitz, 27, who once smoked half a pack of cigarettes a day, said he had used nicotine patches and gum to try to stop. But mango-flavored Juul was the only thing that helped him quit six months ago, he said. “I’m afraid I’d have to go back to smoking regular cigarettes,” Mr. Horowitz said.

The potentially fatal disease, and its mysterious cause, have led to renewed calls from public health officials, parents, educators and lawmakers for a ban on the largely unregulated industry of vaping products; it has also spurred an investigation by the Centers for Disease Control, which warned consumers against buying bootleg cannabis and e-cigarette products.

In response, several state attorneys general, including New York’s, Letitia James, called for the federal government to ban flavored e-cigarettes in May, and state legislators in California and Massachusetts introduced bills to block their sale.

Last week, New Jersey’s Senate president, Stephen M. Sweeney, took the effort to curb e-cigarette use even further by introducing legislation that would ban the sale of all electronic smoking devices. If passed, it would make New Jersey the first state to enact a complete ban on the product.

“The health and safety and even the lives of young people are at risk,” Mr. Sweeney, a Democrat, said in a statement. “We should not allow another generation to get addicted to a product that lowers life expectancy and seriously damages their heart and lungs.”


Questions Using Close Reading and Critical Thinking: 

  1. The first section of an article should answer the questions “Who?”, “What?”, “When?”, and “Where?” Identify the four Ws of this article. (Note: The rest of the news article provides details on the why and/or how.)
  2. Does this article have any bias? Why or why not?
  3. Why did Michigan, and now New York, ban the sale of flavored e-cigarettes? 
  4. Explain why tobacco and menthol-flavored products are not banned and why the American Lung Association disagrees with this decision.
  5. How has Juul Labs, which dominates the e-cigarette market, already taken steps to stop some sales of flavored products? How will smaller businesses be affected in the states banning flavored e-cigarettes?
  6. What was the decision on a recent bill passed in New York that takes effect in November? What are other states doing to further the ban on the electronic smoking industry?
  7. Analyze the benefits and costs of banning flavored e-cigarettes. What are some of the unintended negative outcomes of such a ban?
  8. Do you think that the federal government should ban vaping and the sale of e-cigarettes for all ages? Why or why not? Defend your position.

Read original article here: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/15/nyregion/vaping-ban-ny.html

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Tell us how we can improve this post? If you would like a response, please include an email address.

Leave a Reply